Wednesday, February 13, 2008

Can Private Industry Solve the Energy Crisis?

Is it wise for America to assume that private industry can solve the problem they created? No.

The function of a public corporation is to provide a return to shareholders. As the market has demonstrated, vertically integrated public corporations, like the petroleum industry, receive a higher return to shareholders when (a) commodity prices are high, (b) manufacturing is running at peak utilization rates, (c) orders are backlogged allowing efficient supply chain and inventory management, and (d) operations are not impeded by bureaucratic or environmental gridlock. All these factors fly in the face of the notion that American energy security can be managed by public corporations. These issues are a matter of national security and as we have seen demonstrated by China, Brazil, Singapore, Venezuela, Nigeria, Malaysia, Indonesia and others, these nations recognize that national survival requires a degree of national control as it relates to energy.


These points are addressed in JD's detailed Future of Energy position paper. Click here to read more.

Click here to listen to JD's radio program. This is part one of four parts. All are posted on his website.

Looming Global Energy Crisis

The ancient book Balance and Harmony describes knowledge and wisdom this way: Deep knowledge is to be aware of a disturbance before the disturbance occurs. Wisdom is to know the answer to a question before the question is asked.

Are we facing a looming global energy crisis? Based on ancient wisdom, the important questions we must answer include:

1. Is total energy demand really as great as predicted?
2. Will refined crude products be able to keep up with demand?
3. Can non-conventional sources maintain their current share of supply?
4. What will happen to the price of crude oil?
5. How will the rest of the world react to higher prices and limited power?
6. How can the United States reduce its’ energy dependence?
7. How can conventional and non-conventional sources of energy overcome the critical shortages in resources and equipment?
8. Is it wise for America to assume that private industry can solve the problem they created?

These points are addressed in my presidential position paper. Clear here to read.

Click here to listen to my radio program. This is part one, there are four parts listed on my site.

Contrary to conventional wisdom, we cannot evaluate energy-industry decisions in isolation from other industries, raw materials, nations or the combined systemic needs. But many energy forecasters, including the Energy Information Agency (EIA), are doing just this. The result is an EIA Outlook that ignores the systemic pressures of what happens when everyone is vying for the last available welder, shipyard, carbon steel pipe, acre of farmable land, available crane or gallon of water.

Conventional wisdom will not show us the way out of this problem. It is helpful to call upon the wisdom of the late Albert Einstein, who once said, “We cannot solve problems using the same kind of thinking that created them.”

Running out of Crude Apples

A metaphor – consider an apple is a million barrels of crude equivalent a day

The macro situation on the energy industry is complicated. It is especially more complex in today’s world where commerce overlaps national borders instantaneously, supply chains are interlocked across a dozen countries, and commodities are now interdependent. This new world, born in 1995 with global systems and the Internet, began to walk in 2000 and before we knew it was alive, was sprinting by 2005. Since then crude oil has tripled in price, gold and corn futures have almost doubled, and the world fuel tank is running on empty. The primary reason for the explosive growth is because multinational companies modernized the east when technology and telecommunications created global access. This opened the world for three billion new people and now we are running out of fuel and electrical power - in cities across every country, on every continent. The future of energy is looking like a perfect storm, created by a ten year old global economy, swirling so fast that it is sucking us into a dark abyss where a convergence of industries and countries compete for the last available crane, rig, platform, pipeline, skilled welder, offshore crewman, steam turbine, or tanker filled with crude.

Given that energy is the life-blood of economic development, the battle for energy and power is a matter of national security for every nation. But many do not understand the complete picture. In order to fully appreciate the situation, pretend that one apple represents a million barrels a day of equivalent crude oil, a basis for measuring energy demand.

Back in 1995, the world consumed about 70 apples a day and had enough trees, trucks and people to harvest perhaps a dozen extra apples a day. But today, the world is making 86 crude apples a day and eating 86 crude apples a day. This has people worried because it’s not as if we have a year’s supply of apples in the pantry if something goes wrong. The United States, the largest consumer, eats 22 apples every day, and has perhaps l5 days of edible apples in their pantry (usable inventory) and another 30 days in the freezer (Strategic Petroleum Reserve). Since the world is eating the apples as fast as we can harvest them, some people are worried about receiving their daily ration of apples. This has never happened before and some people are in denial, especially the apple farmers.

Since we have so little spare capacity between apple supply and demand, the price of apples has quadrupled since 1995 and the average American family has used up their entire disposable income from their last two pay raises just to keep buying apples. They have been demanding that the nation make more apples, but there are many problems. First, it takes ten years for the seedling to bear fruit. Second, although were not out of apple trees (oil reserves), the economy has been growing so well that the world is flat out of experienced farmers, not enough people are graduating from apple farming school, the apple harvesters (refiners) are running at maximum capacity, and there are not enough trucks, drivers, and experienced apple pickers to make any more. The apple farmers (petroleum industry) tell us not to worry, we have enough apple trees to last a hundred years. What the farmers fail to acknowledge is that we are not beavers and we don’t eat the tree. We eat the apple.

Why don’t we grow other fruits to replace the apples? We do and apples only represent 80 percent of the total fruit (energy) we consume. The world actually eats another 22 pieces of fruit a day to survive; 12 organic oranges (wind, hydro and solar), 5 prickly pears (nuclear) and one more increasing rare fruit only available in emerging nations, 5 kiwi’s (wood). What people don’t realize is that the kiwis are only going to last just so long, and the assumed expansion plans for organic oranges and prickly pears are running into problems of their own. First, most people have become hooked on apples and they have built entire businesses all around apples, so the farmers who are trying to grow organic oranges and prickly pears are running into resistance from the apple addicts. Secondly, all of the farmers for organic oranges and prickly pears are facing the same problem as the apple farmers – the seedlings take ten years to grow, there are not enough trained farmers, and all the equipment to harvest, transport, and sell the organic oranges and prickly pears are back ordered or non-existent. As a result, all the fruit farmers’ plans are slipping by three to five years. There is actually one more problem for the prickly pears (nuclear), although they are cheap, healthy and safe, three people died from a bad pear when they first started growing them and now the pears have a bad reputation in America. Everyone in the industrialized nations has forgotten about the kiwis (wood) since those are only used in exotic places like Asia but the people eating kiwis are actually quite worried because there is only so many left and when they are gone, they too must start eating apples or oranges but they cannot afford them.

To read my presidential position paper, visit

What do we do about it? Click here to read my position paper for the next president.

Click here to listen to my radio program on the looming global energy crisis. This is part one, there are four parts listed in the Energy category on my website.

Riddles for Presidential Candidates

Answers are written from right to left below, as in Hebrew.

A. What is more powerful than God and scarier than the devil?

B. What is more important than GDP or the war in Iraq?


Answers:

A. gnihton
B. ygrene

Without "answer B above" there is no economy and we cannot fight a war.

JD Messinger Radio Show